Heated Mattress vs Electric Blanket: Which Is Better?

By Baasil Abid4 min read

Heated Mattress vs Electric Blanket: Which Is Better?

Once the nights draw in, plenty of people start looking for something warmer than another duvet. Two options come up again and again: an electric blanket, or a mattress with the heating built in. They do the same job, but they're not the same thing to live with.

What's the difference?

An electric blanket is a layer of fabric with heating elements running through it. You put it on top of your mattress (an underblanket) or over yourself (an overblanket), and it stays put with straps or elasticated corners. A heated mattress has the heating built into the mattress itself, so you make the bed as normal. You can see how ours are set up on the [link: heated mattresses] page.

How they feel

Underblankets can bunch up beneath the sheet, and some people notice the wires or the extra layer. A heated mattress feels like a normal mattress with warmth coming up through it. That's the idea, anyway. Comfort is personal, so try one if you can.

Day to day

Blankets are cheaper to buy, you can move them between beds, and you can put them away in summer. The downside is fitting them, tucking them in and taking them off every time you change the bed. A heated mattress has nothing to fit or store, but it costs more because you're buying the mattress and the heating in one go.

Safety and care

Whichever you choose, follow the maker's instructions. For electric blankets, the usual UK advice is to replace one at least every ten years, get it tested every two or three years, and never buy one second-hand. Check it regularly for scorch marks, fraying, exposed wires or a damaged cable, and stop using it if you see any of those.

A heated mattress needs the same common sense. Don't fold or crush the heated parts, keep drinks well away from it, and look over the cable and controller from time to time. If you've got a question about a particular model, just ask us.

Running costs

Both are generally cheaper than heating a whole room overnight, because they only warm the bed. For a real figure, check the wattage on the product page and your own tariff rather than trusting a rule of thumb.

Which one suits you?

An electric blanket makes sense if you want the lowest price, only need warmth for part of the year, or want something you can move between beds. A heated mattress makes more sense if you're due a new mattress anyway, like a bed that looks and feels normal, and can't be bothered fitting and removing a blanket.

A word of caution

If you or someone in your home has reduced feeling, a condition that affects how you regulate temperature, or limited mobility, check with your GP before using any electric bed warmer. These products aren't generally recommended for anyone who can't feel or react to heat, or for very young children. Always read the safety guidance that comes with the product.

Our view

If you just want warm toes this winter, a decent blanket in good condition does the job. If you'd rather have the warmth built in, a heated mattress is worth a look. Not sure which suits your bed and budget? Try our [link: mattress quiz] or come and see us at the Falkirk showroom and we'll talk you through it.

Frequently asked questions

Is a heated mattress safe?

Used as the instructions say, and kept in good condition, heated bedding is designed to be safe. But it isn't right for everyone, such as people who can't feel or react to heat, and very young children. Read the safety guidance that comes with the product.

Can I leave a heated mattress on all night?

That depends on the product, so check the instructions for yours. Some people prefer to warm the bed before getting in and then turn it down or off. Follow what the maker recommends.

Can I use an electric blanket on top of a heated mattress?

Don't layer heating products unless the instructions for both say it's fine. It's safest to use one at a time.

How long does an electric blanket last?

The usual UK advice is to replace one at least every ten years, and to have it tested every two to three years. Stop using it straight away if you see scorch marks, fraying or damaged wires.

Are they expensive to run?

Both are generally cheaper than heating a whole room overnight, because they only warm the bed. For a real figure, check the wattage on the product page and your own electricity tariff.

This is general advice, not medical or safety advice for any one person. Always follow the instructions that come with your product.